Trapped in the Ideal | Your Best American Boyfriend | Mitski

Mitski's song "Your Best American Boyfriend" is a poignant reflection on the complexities of relationships and personal identity. The lyrics delve into the theme of feeling trapped in a relationship that no longer serves one's true self, with the protagonist grappling with the idea of conforming to societal expectations versus staying authentic.

The song's narrative follows Mitski as she reminisces about her past relationship with an American boyfriend, who represents a particular idealized notion of love and freedom. However, this memory is tainted by the realization that she was compromising her own desires and values in order to fit into his vision of what their life together should be. The lyrics "He said 'I'll take you to the city, we'll get married and have kids'" convey a sense of surrender, as Mitski's protagonist feels pressured to conform to traditional American ideals.

The chorus, with its repetition of the phrase "your best American boyfriend," becomes a lamentation of sorts, highlighting the ways in which societal expectations can suffocate individuality. Mitski's haunting vocals bring this emotional weight to life, imbuing the song with a sense of longing and disconnection. Her lyrics are both personal and relatable, speaking to the universal experience of feeling trapped in a relationship that no longer nourishes one's soul.

Ultimately, "Your Best American Boyfriend" is a powerful exploration of the tension between personal identity and societal pressure. Mitski's song serves as a reminder that true freedom lies in embracing our authentic selves, even if it means venturing outside the comfort zone of traditional expectations.