When What Could Have Been Haunts What Is | Should'Ve Been Lover | Sufjan Stevens

Sufjan Stevens' song "Should've Been Lover" is a poignant reflection on missed opportunities and the consequences of our choices. The lyrics are deeply personal, drawing from Stevens' own experiences with love, loss, and regret.

The song's narrative revolves around a past relationship that went awry due to the protagonist's inability to express their true feelings. The chorus, "I should've been your lover," is a haunting admission of what could have been if only they had taken the leap and confessed their emotions. This realization serves as a catalyst for introspection, with Stevens probing the complexities of love, heartbreak, and self-awareness.

Throughout the song, Stevens' poetic lyrics paint a vivid picture of the fragility of human connection. He sings about the fleeting nature of relationships, where moments of intimacy and understanding can be swiftly followed by disconnection and heartache. This theme is underscored by the song's melancholic melody, which features a soaring chorus and introspective verses that linger in the listener's mind.

The lyrics also touch on themes of regret and longing, as Stevens reflects on what could have been if only he had taken the chance to express his feelings. The line "I'm still searching for your light" is particularly poignant, suggesting a deep sense of yearning and the ongoing quest for connection and understanding. This introspective quality adds depth and nuance to the song's emotional impact.

Ultimately, "Should've Been Lover" is a powerful exploration of the human experience, delving into the complexities of love, heartbreak, and self-awareness. Through his lyrics and melody, Stevens has crafted a song that resonates with listeners on a profound level, inviting them to reflect on their own experiences with love and loss.