Shadows of What Could Have Been | Should'Ve Been | Sufjan Stevens

Sufjan Stevens' song "Should've Been" is a poignant reflection on relationships that didn't quite work out as planned. The song's narrator looks back on past encounters, wondering what could have been if only certain decisions had been made differently.

The lyrics are filled with longing and regret, as the protagonist grapples with the idea of missed opportunities. "I should've been your friend," he repeats, acknowledging that his own insecurities and fears held him back from forming deeper connections with others. This self-awareness is a key theme throughout the song, as Stevens' introspective lyrics invite listeners to confront their own shortcomings and doubts.

One of the most striking aspects of "Should've Been" is its use of metaphorical language to describe these missed connections. "I should've been the sun that shone on your face," Stevens sings, equating his absence with a lack of warmth or illumination in someone's life. This imagery adds depth and nuance to the song's exploration of regret and what-ifs.

Musically, "Should've Been" features Stevens' distinctive vocals and acoustic guitar work, creating an intimate atmosphere that draws listeners into the narrative. The song's tempo is measured and deliberate, allowing the lyrics to take center stage and convey the emotional weight of these memories.

Ultimately, "Should've Been" is a powerful exploration of the human experience – our capacity for connection, our tendency to hold back, and our need to learn from our mistakes. As Stevens' narrator concludes, "I should've been your friend, but I wasn't there," we're left with a sense of longing and a desire to make amends in our own relationships.