The meaning of But Is It Fair? by Genesis

"But Is It Fair?" is a song by the English rock band Genesis, released in 1970 on their album "Nursery Cryme". The song's lyrics are a commentary on the societal norms and expectations placed upon individuals, particularly in relationships.

The song's protagonist asks the titular question, wondering if it's fair to expect others to conform to certain standards or behaviors. He laments the pressure to present a perfect exterior, hiding one's true feelings and desires beneath a veneer of normalcy. The lyrics touch on themes of social conformity, emotional suppression, and the suffocating nature of societal expectations.

Throughout the song, Peter Gabriel's distinctive vocals deliver a poignant critique of the constraints placed upon individuals by society. He sings about the fear of being ostracized or rejected for not meeting certain standards, highlighting the tension between personal freedom and external pressures.

Musically, "But Is It Fair?" is characterized by Genesis's signature blend of progressive rock and folk influences. The song features intricate instrumental arrangements, with a prominent piano riff and soaring vocal harmonies that add depth to the lyrics' emotional resonance.

Overall, "But Is It Fair?" serves as a powerful commentary on the societal pressures that can stifle individuality and creativity. The song's thought-provoking lyrics continue to resonate with listeners today, offering a poignant reflection on the human experience and our ongoing struggle for self-expression in the face of external expectations.